| Name | What | Region | Country | Lat | Long | Elev Ft. | Pop Est |
| Shackport | city | New York | United States | 42.38667 | -74.925 | 2201 | 1365 |
| Shadigee | city | New York | United States | 43.375 | -78.38917 | 255 | 2290 |
| Shady | city | New York | United States | 42.06639 | -74.15972 | 1289 | 4363 |
| Shady Corner Curve | city | New York | United States | 44.21722 | -73.93139 | 2526 | 1990 |
| Shaker Crossing | city | New York | United States | 42.73417 | -77.84889 | 600 | 7267 |
| Shaker Place | city | New York | United States | 43.32417 | -74.52472 | 1683 | 43 |
| Shakers | city | New York | United States | 42.73944 | -73.81167 | 298 | 76755 |
| Shamrock | city | New York | United States | 42.90083 | -76.36194 | 1197 | 3472 |
| Shandaken | city | New York | United States | 42.12 | -74.39583 | 1469 | 1104 |
| Shandelee | city | New York | United States | 41.87889 | -74.87167 | 2139 | 2291 |
| Sharon | city | New York | United States | 42.76111 | -74.53306 | 1181 | 2186 |
| Sharon Center | city | New York | United States | 42.78 | -74.58694 | 1496 | 2212 |
| Sharon Springs | city | New York | United States | 42.79583 | -74.6175 | 1391 | 2776 |
| Sharon Station | city | New York | United States | 41.88333 | -73.52056 | 616 | 3085 |
| Shaw Corners | city | New York | United States | 43.08222 | -74.0325 | 1190 | 2585 |
| Shawnee | city | New York | United States | 43.12806 | -78.83806 | 600 | 8785 |
| Sheds | city | New York | United States | 42.81111 | -75.83056 | 1397 | 2076 |
| Sheenwater | city | New York | United States | 42.99528 | -79.01611 | 570 | 23711 |
| Sheepshead Bay | city | New York | United States | 40.59111 | -73.945 | 13 | 962497 |
| Shekomeko | city | New York | United States | 41.92806 | -73.59944 | 826 | 3015 |
| Shelby Basin | city | New York | United States | 43.21583 | -78.43083 | 518 | 10882 |
| Shelby Center | city | New York | United States | 43.18944 | -78.3925 | 587 | 9557 |
| Sheldon | city | New York | United States | 42.73722 | -78.41889 | 1525 | 2448 |
| Sheldon Center | city | New York | United States | 42.73778 | -78.38861 | 1640 | 2031 |
| Sheldon Hall | city | New York | United States | 42.11806 | -79.31472 | 1309 | 19212 |
| Sheldrake | city | New York | United States | 42.665 | -76.70194 | 380 | 2045 |
| Sheldrake Springs | city | New York | United States | 42.65833 | -76.755 | 856 | 2066 |
| Shelter Island | city | New York | United States | 41.06806 | -72.33917 | 49 | 6478 |
| Shelter Island Heights | city | New York | United States | 41.08389 | -72.35639 | 49 | 5614 |
| Shenandoah | city | New York | United States | 41.52861 | -73.78972 | 374 | 10854 |
| Shenorock | city | New York | United States | 41.33167 | -73.73861 | 498 | 32585 |
| Shepard Settlement | city | New York | United States | 42.99528 | -76.38361 | 990 | 9196 |
| Shepards Corner | city | New York | United States | 43.105 | -76.83972 | 465 | 4406 |
| Sherburne | city | New York | United States | 42.67806 | -75.49889 | 1095 | 2604 |
| Sherburne Four Corners | city | New York | United States | 42.64806 | -75.54694 | 1095 | 2636 |
| Sheridan | city | New York | United States | 42.48833 | -79.2375 | 770 | 2560 |
| Sherlock Corners | city | New York | United States | 42.89667 | -76.56639 | 790 | 32002 |
| Sherman | city | New York | United States | 42.15917 | -79.59556 | 1587 | 2023 |
| Sherman Park | city | New York | United States | 41.12667 | -73.77556 | 396 | 45266 |
| Shermans Bay | city | New York | United States | 42.09889 | -79.34833 | 1374 | 7441 |
| Sherrill | city | New York | United States | 43.07361 | -75.59861 | 498 | 10743 |
| Sherwood | city | New York | United States | 42.76083 | -76.62167 | 1023 | 2260 |
| Sherwood Knolls | city | New York | United States | 43.0375 | -76.25944 | 767 | 34648 |
| Sherwood Park | city | New York | United States | 42.60472 | -73.71806 | 269 | 53513 |
| Shin Hollow | city | New York | United States | 41.40472 | -74.61583 | 869 | 5805 |
| Shinhopple | city | New York | United States | 42.03861 | -75.06806 | 1095 | 781 |
| Shinnecock Hills | city | New York | United States | 40.89083 | -72.46417 | 49 | 8357 |
| Shirley | city | New York | United States | 42.57667 | -78.91389 | 1076 | 4020 |
| Shirley | city | New York | United States | 40.80139 | -72.86806 | 49 | 54368 |
| Shokan | city | New York | United States | 41.97333 | -74.2125 | 649 | 3141 |
| Sholam | city | New York | United States | 41.82083 | -74.41083 | 1141 | 1855 |
| Shongo | city | New York | United States | 42.13861 | -78.77833 | 1397 | 3030 |
| Shongo | city | New York | United States | 42.01806 | -77.89722 | 1719 | 1670 |
| Shooktown | city | New York | United States | 43.15944 | -78.66333 | 603 | 26968 |
| Shore Acres | city | New York | United States | 42.15028 | -79.38028 | 1309 | 3746 |
| Shore Acres | city | New York | United States | 43.34694 | -77.85111 | 246 | 4592 |
| Shore Acres | city | New York | United States | 40.94694 | -73.72444 | 9 | 97101 |
| Shore Acres | city | New York | United States | 41.0025 | -72.55028 | 3 | 6273 |
| Shore Haven | city | New York | United States | 42.31389 | -79.64194 | 633 | 2068 |
| Shore Oaks | city | New York | United States | 43.51861 | -76.3575 | 275 | 2590 |
| Shoreham | city | New York | United States | 40.95722 | -72.90806 | 124 | 28949 |
| Shorelands | city | New York | United States | 42.24917 | -79.46833 | 1400 | 2573 |
| Shorewood | city | New York | United States | 42.42861 | -77.10278 | 1122 | 1656 |
| Short Tract | city | New York | United States | 42.45222 | -78.01472 | 1683 | 1028 |
| Shortsville | city | New York | United States | 42.95583 | -77.22111 | 623 | 10309 |
| Shrub Oak | city | New York | United States | 41.3275 | -73.82 | 505 | 40296 |
| Shuetown | city | New York | United States | 43.62028 | -75.32889 | 1020 | 701 |
| Shultis Corners | city | New York | United States | 42.05028 | -74.06917 | 400 | 7466 |
| Shumaker Crossing | city | New York | United States | 42.89444 | -76.57 | 793 | 32002 |
| Shumla | city | New York | United States | 42.38667 | -79.29889 | 1217 | 10887 |
| Shunpike | city | New York | United States | 41.82861 | -73.70889 | 597 | 4283 |
| Shurtleff | city | New York | United States | 44.25528 | -74.745 | 1525 | 220 |
| Shushan | city | New York | United States | 43.09028 | -73.34333 | 574 | 2065 |
| Shutter Corners | city | New York | United States | 42.67528 | -74.25333 | 698 | 3907 |
|
|